25 Min Arrive! Fast, Reliable
Automotive-Residential-Commercial
24/7 Emergency Mobile Locksmith Services in Bay Shore, NY
Our Services
Key emergencies don’t wait for business hours. If you discover your car key is gone in the middle of the night or first thing in the morning in Bay Shore, we dispatch immediately. Our technician arrives near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal or at your home in about 25 minutes and fabricates the replacement on the spot — transponder programming included — so you’re driving again without a tow or an appointment.
A broken key blade stuck inside a lock or ignition cylinder requires patience and precision to extract cleanly. In Bay Shore, near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal or anywhere you’re parked, our auto locksmiths use purpose-built extraction tools to remove the fragment without damaging the cylinder — then cut and program a fresh replacement on-site so you drive away with a working key and an intact lock.
Locked out in Bay Shore at noon or at 2am? It doesn’t matter when. We operate 24/7 and our average response time across Bay Shore — including near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal — is about 25 minutes. One call gets a mobile tech rolling to your location with the exact tools for your specific vehicle: slim jim for older door mechanisms, air wedge and long-reach for modern frames.
A failed ignition cylinder means the car isn’t moving without help. In Bay Shore, our mobile locksmith arrives near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal with the parts and tools to replace the cylinder on-site — including re-keying the new unit to your existing key. Full workshop-level repair done at your curb, no tow truck required.
A house lockout in Bay Shore at midnight or on a Sunday afternoon near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal gets the same immediate response from us: dispatch within minutes, ~25-minute arrival, and non-destructive entry. Our locksmiths are trained on all major residential lock brands and use the right tools — not improvised ones — to open the door correctly and completely.
Ready to upgrade locks at your Bay Shore home or rental property near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal? We arrive with a full selection of residential deadbolts, knob sets, and high-security cylinder options and install on-site. Every job includes frame assessment, strike plate reinforcement where needed, and a complete test of the lock mechanism before we leave your property.
Lost a key somewhere in Bay Shore near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal and not sure where it ended up? Don’t wait. We re-key your locks the same day — modifying the internal pin combination so the lost key opens nothing. The hardware stays in place; only the working key changes. Fast, affordable, and done right at your door.
Locked out of your Bay Shore business near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal? We operate 24/7 because commercial emergencies don’t follow business hours. Our mobile locksmiths arrive in about 25 minutes, open the lock without damage, and offer full re-keying service during the same visit so you can control access immediately. Experienced with office, retail, industrial, and hospitality properties.
Ready to upgrade the commercial locks at your Bay Shore property near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal? We assess your doors, recommend the appropriate ANSI grade and hardware brand for your use case, and complete the installation on-site — including strike plate reinforcement, cylinder alignment, and a full operational test. Same-day service available for most commercial lock installations in Bay Shore.
Von Duprin, Falcon, Detex — we supply and install the push bar brands trusted by commercial property managers and fire marshals across Long Island, including Bay Shore. Near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal or anywhere in Bay Shore, we complete the installation with proper door frame assessment, hardware anchoring, and a full push-test to confirm compliant operation. Same-day service available.
About Us
For over 35 years, NY AUTO KEYS has been the trusted mobile locksmith serving Bay Shore and all of Long Island, NY — operated by 23 Car Key Locksmith.
From the busy streets near Main Street and the Bay Shore Marina ferry terminal to the quieter residential blocks throughout Bay Shore, NY Auto Keys mobile locksmiths respond to car key emergencies, lockouts, and residential and commercial lock work every day. We’ve been serving Long Island since 1991, and Bay Shore is part of the community we treat as our own — certified technicians, on-site service, and a fair price every time.
We believe that every lock and key tells a story of trust. That’s why we handle every job – big or small – with precision, care, and honesty. From emergency lockouts to advanced access control systems, our team uses modern tools and techniques to ensure your complete peace of mind.
We’re not just locksmiths — we’re your security partners, dedicated to protecting what matters most.
Solving problems since 1991
Trusted Residential, Commercial & Automotive Locksmith Services in Bay Shore, Suffolk County, NY
NY AUTO KEYS, is a trade name operated by 23 car key locksmith inc. An Independent, Locally-owned locksmith company serves Long Island NY
Extensive knowledge and expertise in all facets of vehicle, commercial and residential areas.
Why choose us
Fully Licensed, Bonded, And Insured
Certified Locksmiths
Our company operates with full licensing and insurance, and is handled by trained professionals following strict safety standards.
Customer Support
We don’t leave until the job is done right. Our goal is to make every customer feel safe, secure, and confident in our service.
Quickest Response
Our mobile locksmith units are always on the move, ready to reach you quickly and solve your problem on the spot
Extensive Knowledge
We invest in the latest locksmith tools and techniques to handle every job with precision. Ensuring quick, damage-free service.
4.8
Our average customer rating is 4.8 / 5 based on 2.549 reviews
What Our Customers Say
Common Questions
Frequently Asked Questions — Locksmith in Bay Shore, NY
Our average response time across Long Island, including Bay Shore, is approximately 25 minutes. We run mobile units throughout the area at all hours — day, night, weekends, holidays. The moment you call, we dispatch and give you a real ETA right away.
Yes. This is one of our most common calls. We generate a new key from scratch using your vehicle’s VIN and our on-site cutting and programming equipment — covering transponder keys, smart keys, push-to-start fobs, and proximity remotes for virtually all makes and models. No tow, no existing key required.
No. We use non-destructive entry methods on every job. For vehicles: professional slim jim and air wedge tools that leave zero marks. For homes: picking and decode techniques suited to your specific lock hardware. Drilling is an absolute last resort — and we always explain the situation before touching anything.
Re-keying changes the internal pin configuration of your existing lock so old keys no longer work — no new hardware, lower cost. A full lock change means new hardware entirely, which is better if the lock is worn, low-grade, or you want a genuine security upgrade. We’ll assess your doors in Bay Shore and give you an honest recommendation.
We operate 24/7 because emergencies don’t keep business hours. You receive a clear price quote before any work begins — no surprise charges after the job is done. Our pricing is the same regardless of the time or day.
We accept all major credit and debit cards — Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover — plus Zelle and cash. No surcharges on card payments, ever.
In most cases yes — and significantly faster. Dealerships require a tow and an appointment, and typically charge two to three times more for the same transponder or smart key programming job. We come to your location in Bay Shore, complete the job on-site, and charge a fair, upfront price.
Yes. NY Auto Keys is a trade name of 23 Car Key Locksmith Inc. — a fully licensed, bonded, and insured locksmith company headquartered in Freeport, NY. We operate legally and carry full credentials across all of Long Island including Bay Shore and all surrounding Suffolk County communities.
We Accept All Payment Methods
Pay the way that works for you — no surcharges on card payments, no minimum cash requirement.
